[Mesa-users] Gaia photometry with MESA colors

Richard Townsend townsend at astro.wisc.edu
Wed Sep 30 20:29:20 UTC 2026


Hi again Alex —

As a follow-up, it looks like MESA’s colors module isn’t accounting for the fact that the passband data for GAIA (which come from the Spanish Virtual Observatory, SVO) assume a photon-counting detector, rather than an energy-counting detector. 

I’ve opened a GitHub issue describing the problem here:

https://github.com/MESAHub/mesa/issues/1069

best wishes,

Rich


> On Sep 30, 2026, at 2:49 PM, Richard Townsend via Mesa-users <mesa-users at lists.mesastar.org> wrote:
> 
> Thanks, Alex. I can reproduce the speedyfit absolute magnitudes and colors to within ~ 0.02 using my own MSG library:
> 
> https://msg.readthedocs.io/en/stable/index.html
> 
> (this is with the C3K grid). So, this does look like an issue with colors in MESA. 
> 
> I’m sure this will get fixed quickly by Niall (the colors developer), but if you can’t wait, then MSG should be able to meet your needs for flexible post-processing (it can also be run on-the-fly within MESA, but I need to put together a test-suite example of how to do it).
> 
> cheers,
> 
> Rich
> 
>> On Sep 30, 2026, at 1:44 PM, Alex Duran <alex.duran at postgrado.uv.cl> wrote:
>> 
>> Hi Rich,
>> 
>> I am sending you the data you asked for some specific points for a 1 Msun track (which corresponds to the circles in the attached figure). I am also sending you the history file from the simulation in case you need it, and the output data from speedyfit too.
>> Thank you for your help,
>> Cheers
>> --
>> Alex Durán-Reyes
>> 
>> De: Richard Townsend <townsend at astro.wisc.edu>
>> Enviado: miércoles, 30 de septiembre de 2026 11:32
>> Para: Alex Duran <alex.duran at postgrado.uv.cl>
>> Cc: mesa-users at lists.mesastar.org <mesa-users at lists.mesastar.org>; Diego Benitez <diego.benitezp at postgrado.uv.cl>; Felipe Jesús Ahumada Quiroz <felipe.ahumadaq at postgrado.uv.cl>
>> Asunto: Re: [Mesa-users] Gaia photometry with MESA colors
>> Hi Alex —
>> 
>> Can you post example values for a single point on one evolutionary track — i.e., Teff, log(g), [M/H], and radius for the star, and then the Gabs, GBP and GRP values you get from MESA and from speedyfit. This will help us dig into what’s going wrong without having to actually do a MESA run.
>> 
>> Many thanks,
>> 
>> Rich
>> 
>>> On Sep 29, 2026, at 1:47 PM, Alex Duran via Mesa-users <mesa-users at lists.mesastar.org> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Dear all,
>>> 
>>> I hope you are doing well. Some colleagues and I are using the MESA colors module (version 26.04.1) to calculate synthetic GAIA photometry for a sample of single low-mass stars (between 1 and 2 solar masses). The code works well, but there appear to be some issues with the calculation of the synthetic GAIA photometry. For some reason, when comparing the results with a sample of selected sources with good astrometry and photometry (errors <10%) from Gaia DR3 within a 100 pc, the tracks from MESA appear to be redder and brighter than expected. I have attached a figure comparing the MESA tracks with the GAIA 100 pc sample.
>>> 
>>> To determine whether or not this is a MESA-related issue, we use speedyfit (https://speedyfit.readthedocs.io/en/latest/) to calculate synthetic photometry based on the atmospheric parameters obtained with MESA, in a manner similar to the operation of the MESA colors module. Upon comparing the results, we observe that the speedyfit photometry (dashed lines in the figure) provides a better fit to the observed GAIA 100 pc sample than the MESA colors photometry (solid lines). Both, speedyfit and MESA used the same atm grid (Kurucz), the only difference might be the ZP.
>>> 
>>> We are wondering what might be causing this. We tried changing the main parameters of the colors module, but that does not work. I am also attaching the inlist file used for the MESA simulations; it is very simple, only including stellar winds and core overshooting.
>>> 
>>> Thank you in advance,
>>> Best regards
>>> --
>>> Alex Durán-Reyes
>>> MSc in Astrophysics, Universidad de Valparaíso
>>> PhD Student in Astrophysics, Universidad de Valparaíso
>>> alex.duran at postgrado.uv.cl
>>> alex.fabian.dr at gmail.com<inlist_colors><synth_phot_low_mass_stars.pdf><synth_phot_low_mass_stars.png>_______________________________________________
>>> mesa-users at lists.mesastar.org
>>> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://lists.mesastar.org/mailman/listinfo/mesa-users__;!!Mak6IKo!JD7pMyR29tzfxsYfczYjFcFqhfODFy4uEskWrkzuYZVAKBlLrnZAaH9VE5jja8Q9Ed63JkNsjITM6J_sBEJ3pD7XYhKe5iw$
>> 
>> 
>> --
>> Rich Townsend • Professor of Astronomy
>> Astronomy Department • University of Wisconsin-Madison
>> Phone: 608-262-1752 • E-mail: rhtownsend at wisc.edu
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> <1Msun_track.pdf><data_points.data><history.data><1.0Msun_speedyfit.data>
> 
> --
> Rich Townsend • Professor of Astronomy
> Astronomy Department • University of Wisconsin-Madison
> Phone: 608-262-1752 • E-mail: rhtownsend at wisc.edu
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> mesa-users at lists.mesastar.org
> https://lists.mesastar.org/mailman/listinfo/mesa-users
> 

--
Rich Townsend • Professor of Astronomy
Astronomy Department • University of Wisconsin-Madison
Phone: 608-262-1752 • E-mail: rhtownsend at wisc.edu







More information about the Mesa-users mailing list