[mesa-users] Calibration of Kjeldsen-Bedding-JCD surface effect power law
stello at physics.usyd.edu.au
stello at physics.usyd.edu.au
Mon Nov 11 05:47:34 EST 2013
Hi Warrick,
Thank you for sharing this. The exercise you have embarked on is one
I have wanted to do for some time but not got around to do, so would
be happy to help where possible.
The 4.25, I think, is just a value Bill found long ago when he did the
first attempt to fit HD49..... Whether he matched it to a solar model
or just found that it gave a good fit for HD49... I am not 100% sure
off (Bill can chip in if he remembers himself...probably not ;0) ).
Where it comes from is however not very important.
Your approach is a sensible one to take [using MESA to find a solar
model at find 'b' by comparing it to, say, BiSON]. However, one
should note that just because b=<your fit result for the Sun> works
for the Sun, does not mean it is the most appropriate b-value for
another star....not to mention using a power law to correct the freqs.
What I am trying to say is: there is a limit to which one should seek
to obtain the 'right' b-parameter.
That said, which solar calibration should you use? MESA now has a
second option for doing a solar calibration, which is in 'astero'.
[dont have access to my MESA stuff so can give you details]. But you
could try use both options in MESA to make your own solar calibrations
and see how much that in the end changes your b-parameter.
Keep playing!
Cheers
Dennis/
Quoting Warrick Ball <wball at astro.physik.uni-goettingen.de>:
> Fellow MESAlians*,
>
> I'm trying to recover the calibration of the Kjeldsen-Bedding-JCD
> surface-effect law [1] in the astero_search routines.
>
> In mesa/star/astero/defaults/astero_search_controls.defaults, one finds
>
> ! surface corrections (see K08 -- ApJ 683, pg 175)
> correction_factor = 0
> ! use this fraction of the correction; set to 0 to skip
> doing corrections.
> correction_b = 4.90d0
>
> So the surface power law is b=4.90. This is the canonical value in
> the paper, based on the calibrations in their models. It is often
> used elsewhere.
>
> In
> mesa/star/test_suite/example_astero/inlist_astero_search_controls,
> there is, instead,
>
> ! surface corrections (see K08 -- ApJ 683, pg 175)
> correction_factor = 1
> ! use this fraction of the correction; set to 0 to skip
> doing corrections.
> l0_n_obs(:) = -1 ! the observed radial orders (ignored if < 0)
> ! the observed radial orders are used in calculating
> surface corrections
> ! if <= 0, use default calculation for radial orders
> correction_b = 4.25d0
>
> So b=4.25. Hmmm...
>
> For any given evolutionary code, what one should probably do is use
> that code to calibrate a solar model, compute the oscillation
> frequencies and fit a power law to the differences with, e.g. the
> BiSON frequencies [2]. So I ran
> mesa/star/test_suite/example_solar_model, saved the final model as
> an FGONG file (attached) and handed that to GYRE, with the JCD
> boundary condition, for l=0,1,2,3 in the range 500 to 4500 uHz. I
> then calculated the difference between the MESA model and the BiSON
> frequencies. A plot is attached.
>
> I then tried fitting the parameters myself. First, I did a fit
> (with scipy.optimize.leastsq) with all the observed frequencies, in
> which case I got b=4.53. I then did a fit just with the radial
> modes, in which case I got b=4.68.
>
> What value should one use? Where did b=4.25 in example_astero come from?
>
> Now, I realise that this probably isn't a settled issue. But in the
> absence of a definitively correct answer, I'll settle for a
> well-justified one! :p As a first note, I know that changing the
> range of frequencies over which one fits modifies the power law.
> Second, the calibrated model seems to show a small offset of about
> 0.5 uHz even at the lowest frequencies. Should I add one or two
> frequencies to the calibration to try to fix this, then fit again?
> Or is the model in example_solar_model outdated, and I should run
> the calibration in solar_calibration myself before fitting? And
> should one fit only to the frequencies in the target of the
> astero_search? e.g. HD 49835?
>
> All input is obviously welcome, and I'm happy to work on this
> problem and report to the community how I progress.
>
> Cheers,
> Warrick
>
> * Is this the correct word? Is there an official stance? :p
>
> [1] http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2008ApJ...683L.175K
> [2] http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2009MNRAS.396L.100B
>
>
> ------------
> Warrick Ball
> Postdoc, Institut für Astrophysik Göttingen
> wball at astro.physik.uni-goettingen.de
> +49 (0) 551 39 5069
----------------------------------------------------------------
This message was sent using IMP, the Internet Messaging Program.
More information about the Mesa-users
mailing list